Designing the content model of training female clients, a qualitative study

Document Type : Research/Original/Regular

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Human Resources, Amin Police University, Tehran, Iran

10.22051/jwfs.2023.43573.2973

Abstract

Creating suitable educational and educational conditions in prisons and special wards for women as a prevention method can be very effective. The aim of the current research was to design the model of educational content for female clients with an inductive, qualitative-exploratory approach. Based on this, the country was divided into 4 geographical regions. The target population was 4 central prisons in Tehran, Ahvaz, Kerman and Tabriz provinces. The statistical sample of participants included 37 female clients, 4 prison chiefs, 31 experts and caregivers. Data collection was done using semi-structured interview until theoretical data saturation and focus group; whose data was analyzed using thematic analysis. From the findings of the research, 364 concepts were extracted in the field of educational components. After combining common concepts through central and selective coding and classification of themes, the resulting educational content model has 56 dimensions (self-awareness, social skills, health and safety, familiarity with prison, legal and educational information, knowledge and attitude), 109 components. life skills, communication skills, role expectations, health and treatment, mental health, life in prison, women's special injuries, judicial and cultural-educational legal knowledge) and 91 sub-components. Also, the life skills component with 18 sub-components and women's special injuries with 16 sub-components became the most important subjects of educational content. The results showed that the content arising from the educational needs and the developed conceptual model can play a significant role in providing a targeted and comprehensive education for this group of women.

Highlights

Background and Purpose

    Implementation of policies and programs aimed at empowering female clients within the Prisons Organization can be achieved through the utilization of a suitable curriculum and adherence to a locally relevant model. Hence, it is imperative to identify the essential and suitable subjects for all imprisoned individuals, particularly female inmates, who represent the focal population of this study. This necessitates a thorough and precise examination, employing established methodologies, to formulate and put together training programs with a well-defined and fitting curriculum (based on identified needs) and requisite content. The significance of education within prisons is underscored by Article 79 of the organization's by-laws, which highlights the provision of specialized and specialized training courses, as well as different cultural and educational programs, to all imprisoned clients. The findings of Larijani and Alimardani (2019) also underscore the imperative of providing training programs for incarcerated women. The present study aims to develop a specialized curricular model tailored for imprisoned women.

Method

The present investigation is classified as applied research in terms of its objective, and it adopts a qualitative research approach specifically focused on inductive theme analysis. Following the end of the interviews, the content analysis was conducted utilizing the Themematic Network Analysis approach proposed by Attride-Stirling (2001). The study encompassed three separate categories: global themes, organizing themes, and basic themes.

Data was gathered from a sample of four prisons, namely Tehran, Ahvaz, Kerman, and Tabriz prisons, comprising a total of 72 participants until data saturation was achieved.

 

 

 

Results

The results indicated that the curriculum model developed for female clients consists of five dimensions, nine components, and 66 sub-components, as outlined in Table 1.

Table 1. The coefficients and significance of the indirect effects of emotion control on marital adjustment

 

Global themes

Organizing thems

Basic themes

Number of basic themes

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Social skill

Life skill

Tolerance increase training, hope in life and vitality, anger management, sociability and adjustment, problem-solving skills, decision-making techniques, stress management, self-esteem improvement training, Assertive training, lifestyle, self-awareness, emotion management and empathy, thinking training, present moment focus training, adaptability, self-motivation, mind control, self-confidence enhancement,

 

18

Communication skill

Effective individual and social communication, effective family relationship

4

Role expectations

Parenting in prison, marital relationships inside prison, maintaining the family epicenter,

 

3

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hygiene and Health

Health and Treatment

Understanding public health in prison, women's particular diseases, Learning about chronic and noncommunicable diseases, as well as their treatments, such as cancer, Learning about infectious diseases like as corona, AIDS, and hepatitis and preventing epidemics, as well as addiction prevention and treatment.

5

Mental health

Religious therapy and religious and moral education, understanding symptoms of mental illnesses such as depression and anxiety.

2

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Familiarity with prison

Life in prison

Rules and responsibilities of prisoners, the introduction of prison officers, post-incarceration protections for prisoners and their families, prisoners' fundamental rights, internal prison and ward regulations, and personal security.

16

Women-specific harms

Social and familial rejection and disapproval, the obligation to maintain familial communication, inadequate legal knowledge, familial estrangement, physical distress resulting from psychosis, psychopathological conditions in female clients, women being influenced by external factors, feminine traits, the sense of confinement, transmission of criminal and delinquent knowledge, decreased tolerance levels, the depressive impact on their dependent children, normalization of female absence within the family, heightened violence among their dependent children, and the breakdown of family cohesion.

6

Legal information

Legal and judicial knowledge

Legal and criminal laws, knowledge of substance-related crimes and their punishments, the judicial process, case follow-up, check and promissory note regulations, and the conditions for suspending the execution of the sentence.

6

Educational information

Cultural and educational

Memorizing the Quran, gaining familiarity with Quranic concepts and teachings, rulings, Islamic ethics, planning for leisure time, and free-time activities.

6

 

The findings in the table above indicate that emotional control indirectly influences marital adjustment, mediated through marital intimacy (p-value<.05).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Discussion & Conclusion

The findings indicate that the dimension of "social skill," consisting of 25 basic themes, achieved the highest ranking in comparison to the other dimensions. The findings presented in this study align with the research conducted by Samari (2016). On the other hand, within this specific dimension, the life skill component, consisting of 18 basic themes, holds the most prominent place among the many components.

All three groups of participants placed significant emphasis on the importance of attending the life skill training component. Furthermore, the present findings align with the research conducted by Farahnejad, Mohammadi, and Khorsandi (2019), which emphasizes the significance of life skills training in mitigating abnormal and risky conduct among imprisoned individuals. Baldwin (2018) has confirmed additional elements within this dimension, such as role expectations, emphasizing the maternal role.

Roshanpour and Aghajani (2019) demonstrated a statistically significant correlation between social marginalization and recidivism."Familiarity with prison" is another dimension. The respondents also underlined that providing accurate information regarding prison life, circumstances, and harm has a substantial impact on the mental health of female clients.

Article 109 of the Prisons Organization's bylaws clearly emphasizes teaching prisoners upon arrival and developing and making available to them a manual detailing the prisoner's rights and legal duties. Many individuals within the target community, including managers, prison guards, and experts, strongly emphasize the effectiveness of utilizing Quranic teachings, Islamic ethics, and religious therapy as valuable tools for maintaining and improving the mental well-being of prisoners. These practices also contribute to increasing their sense of hope and purpose in life.The results indicated that social skill training is the most crucial dimension, followed by familiarization with prisons. Additionally, the women in the target community emphasized the importance of increasing their awareness of gender roles and their connection to the institution of the family as a social unit. Some specific themes that were highlighted include parenting in prison, maintaining marital relationships while imprisoned, and maintaining the family unit as the center of their lives.

These findings highlight the fact that playing female roles is a significant concern and priority for women in all forms, conditions, and situations. Holding educational programs aimed at preventing the negative effects of separation from family and the harm associated with prison can have a positive impact on the mental health of female prisoners. Based on the information provided above, the extracted model can be instrumental in developing a comprehensive and focused educational program and content that aligns with the unique dimensions and circumstances of the women's prison.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Attride-Stirling, J. (2001). Thematic networks: an analytic tool for qualitative research. Qualitative research, 1(3), 385-405, doi/abs/10.1177/146879410100100307. [link]
Baldwin, A, Sobolewska, A, & Capper, T. (2020). Pregnant in prison: An integrative literature review. Women and Birth, 33(1), 41-50,doi/abs/10.1177/146879410100100307. [link]
Emadzadeh, M. (2003). The importance of investing in women's education. Journal of Women in Development and Politics, 1(7)115-140. (text in persian) [link]
Farahnejad, A, Mohammadi, R & Khorsandi Yamchi, A. (2020). Evaluating the Effectiveness of Life Skills Teaching in Prisons. Entezam - e - Ejtemaei, 12(4), 169-198. (text in persian) [link]
Head of the Judiciary. (2021). The executive charter of the organization of prisons and security and educational measures of the country. (text in persian) [link]
Hosseinchari, M. (2012). The consequences of prison on the general health of female prisoners based on positive psychology in Kerman and Yazd province prisons. A research project commissioned by the Organization of Prisons and Provisional and Educational Measures of the country. (text in Persian)
Johnston, D. (2006). The wrong road: Efforts to understand the effects of parental crime and incarceration. Criminology & Public Policy, 5(4), 703-719, doi/abs/10.1111/j.1745-9133.2006.00414. [link]
Kazemzadeh, S, Fazli Nasab, B & Mohammadi, S. (2015). The role of women in the health of the family and society. The first international conference on management, economics, accounting and educational sciences, Sari. (text in persian) [link]
Kurdmirza, I. (2013). Examining the consequences of prison for women prisoners. A research project commissioned by the Organization of Prisons and Provisional and Educational Measures of the country. (text in persian)
Larijani, M & Alimardani, Ak. (2020). Investigating prison, correctional and educational processes in Tehran women's prison and presenting a specific model for women's prison. A research project commissioned by the Organization of Prisons and Provisional and Educational Measures of the country. (text in persian)
Lincoln, Y. S, & Guba, E. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. sage. [link]
Mazaheri, M, Khaleghi, N, Rakibi, M & Sarabandi, H. (2011). Prevalence of personality disorders among female prisoners in Zahedan prison. Zahedan Medical Sciences Research Journal (Taib Sharq) 13(3) 46-49. (text in persian) [link]
Moazzami, Sh, Shiravi, M & Salehi, M. (2014). The effect of prison on women's recidivism. Journal of Law and Politics, 11(23)39-58. (text in persian) [link]
Moqtadari Anjam, Z & Farah Bijari, A. (2016). Investigating the psychological well-being of female prisoners (case study: Qezal-Hesar prison). International congress on the role of women in family and community health. (text in persian) [link]
Moshir, Z S. (2017). Sociology of Women's Prisons. first edition, Sociologists Publications, Tehran. (text in persian)
Nejad sabzi, p. (2012). Examining the consequences of prison for female clients in Lorestan province. The research plan of the organization of prisons and security and educational measures of the country. (text in persian)
Roshanpour, M, Mohseni, R A & Aghajani, H. (2019). A Sociological Explanation of the Causes of Social Exclusion of Female Prisoners and Its Effect on the Return to Imprisonment Cycle (Case Study of Prisons in Lorestan Province). Research Journal of Women, 11(34) 1-35. (text in persian) [link]
Sadeghi Fasai, S, Mirhosseini, Z. (2013). Sociological analysis of narratives of women from prison after release. Journal of Women in Development and Politics, 12(3) 345-362. (text in persian) [link]
Samari, H. (2016). Investigating the role of cultural and social education in empowering imprisoned women after release (case study). The second national conference on the position of women in entrepreneurship and sustainable development. (text in persian) [link]
Siegel, Larry J. (2016). Criminology. Translated by Yashar Seif Elahi, Tehran, Naja Vice-Chancellor Publications. (text in persian)
Taghrankar, H. (2006). Alternatives to imprisonment in the realm of women's criminal justice system. Correction and Education Monthly, 55(4)15-18. (text in persian) [link]
Zareipour, M A, Narmayon, N, Mahmoudi, H, Jadgal, KhM & Zare, F. (2016). Investigating Spiritual Health and its Relation to Crime among Female Prisoners in Urmia. Research in religion and health, 4(1), 22-33. (text in persian) [link]
Sirajzadeh, S.H ; Seraj-zade & Nurbakhsh, A. (2008). Examining the Relationship of Socio-economic Development and Female Crime in Iran. Social Psychological Studies of Women, 18(6), 31-54. (text in persian) [link]