Investigating the Factors Affecting the Incidence of Child Abuse (Meta-Analysis of Existing Studies)

Document Type : Research/Original/Regular

Authors

1 Associate prof., Sociology Department, Alzahra university , Tehran, Iran

2 ُSocoilogy Department,University of alzahra, Tehran,Iran.

Abstract

The importance of children as the future makers of a society, on the one hand, and the impact of pleasant or unpleasant childhood experiences on children's future lives, has drawn the attention of many researchers to the social harms of childhood, including child abuse. Such attention to the phenomenon or, more accurately, the social problem of child abuse has led to much research in recent years on the factors affecting child abuse. The present study seeks to investigate the most important factors affecting child abuse in research conducted in Iran using the meta-analysis method. The statistical population of the research is all valid scientific researches in the form of articles and dissertations that have been published in the years 2001 to 1399 on the subject of child abuse. Finally, among the examined documents, 18 selection documents were analyzed using CMA software. The results of the study showed that the variables of conflict and difference in family relationships (0.602) had the most impact and the variable of mother's job (0.222) had the least impact on the occurrence of child abuse.

Highlights

According to the research findings, it can be said that the focus of programs and practical and theoretical measures to reduce violence against children should first of all be on the family system and relationships and interactions between family members. It is noteworthy that considering the cultural context of the Iranian-Islamic society and the deep-rooted religious spirit among Iranian families, one can learn from the teachings of Islam in the field of interactions and actions between parents. And the parent-child benefited. Teachings that can be effective by considering special subtleties and paying attention to the child-adult temperaments and the rights and duties of the two. In this way, an effective step can be taken to reduce child abuse in society. The culture-centered approach, which views violence against children as an educational principle, must also be changed. In this regard, efforts should be made to make members of the community aware that child abuse will have negative effects, even based on a reformist and educational orientation. In addition, measures can be taken at the governmental and governmental levels. Among them is the adoption and implementation of up-to-date and comprehensive laws to protect children in the legal system of society, so that child abusers, both at the family level and the external level can be punished for violence. Reach for it.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Extended Abstract

Background and purpose

Most violence against children or "child abuse" takes place in the home and by family members. Child abuse is a form of "domestic violence". The World Health Organization (WHO) defines child abuse as Child abuse in all forms of physical, emotional, sexual, neglect, exploitation, or exploitation of a child in a relationship based on responsibility. Trust and power refer to the actual or potential harm to a child's health, survival, growth, and dignity (1994; Khak Rangin and Fathi, 2009: 128).

In recent decades, along with foreign researchers, domestic researchers have also studied the phenomenon of child abuse and its roots, and many studies in this field are available. Due to this multiplicity, there is a kind of ambiguity in the field of recognizing the factor or important influencing factors. Therefore, the present study tries to use the meta-analysis method to present a summary of the studies coherently to reach a general and comprehensive summary of the most important factors affecting child abuse. To be more precise, the present study seeks to answer the basic question that in the scientific research conducted in the field of child abuse, what factor or factors have the most and the least impact on the incidence of child abuse in Iranian society?

 

Method

The method used in this study is meta-analysis. Among the various methods of performing and implementing meta-analysis, Hunter and Schmidt's method was used in this study (Ghazi Tabatabai, 2010: 201).

To perform a meta-analysis based on the basic assumptions of this method, the researchers that have examined the issue of child abuse using a quantitative method were selected by a census. The selected researches were published from 2001 through 2009 in the form of master's and doctoral dissertations or the form of articles. Among more than 87 documents examined, 18 documents were identified as suitable for meta-analysis.

 

Results

The analytical findings of the study showed that there is a significant and acceptable relationship between all variables related to victim characteristics and family characteristics with the rate of child abuse (P=0.000). The table below shows the results of the meta-analysis:

Table 1.

Meta-analysis findings of child abuse research hypotheses

Summary of statistics

   

  Assumptions

Effect size in distance 0/95

Heterogeneity test

Model

Combined effects

P-Value

Z-Value

Number of studies

Q

Df

P-Value

I-Squared (I2)

 

The relationship between custody status and child abuse

Fixed

0.164

0.000

10.696

8

93.667

7

0.000

92.527

by accident

0.227

0.000

3.774

The relationship between mother's education and child abuse

Fixed

0.449

0.000

30.415

6

728.748

5

0.000

99.361

by accident

0.468

0.016

2.400

The relationship between child sex and child abuse

Fixed

0.094

0.000

6.369

6

29.240

5

0.000

82.900

by accident

0.089

0.017

2.235

The relationship between family dimension and child abuse

Fixed

0.192

0.000

7.668

5

28.694

4

0.000

86.060

by accident

0.221

0.002

3.137

Relationship between history of child abuse in parents' childhood and child abuse

Fixed

0.200

0.000

6.467

5

5.046

4

0.000

59.94

by accident

0.222

0.000

4.125

 

  1. A) The relationship between family characteristics and child abuse

The relationship between custody status and child abuse in the 8 hypotheses studied is equal to 0.227 positive and significant and weak. The relationship between mother and child abuse education in 6 studies is 0.468 positive and significant and moderate. The results of random combination effects show that the relationship between the family dimension and child abuse in the 5 hypotheses examined is equal to 0.221, positive and weak. The relationship between the history of child abuse in parents' childhood and child abuse in 5 studies, equal to 0.222, is positive and significant and the extent of its effect is poor. The relationship between family social isolation and child abuse in the 5 hypotheses examined is equal to 0.473, positive and significant, and moderate. The relationship between the existence of conflict and conflict in family relationships and child abuse in the 9 hypotheses examined is equal to 0.602, positive and significant, and high. The relationship between father and child abuse education in the 7 hypotheses examined is equal to 0.461, positive and significant, and moderate. The employment relationship between mother and child abuse is positive and significant in the 5 hypotheses examined, equal to 0.222. This independent variable has a small or weak effect on child abuse. The results of random combination effects show that the relationship between the socio-economic status of the family and child abuse, equivalent to 0.448, is positive and significant at the intermediate level. Also, the employment relationship between father and child abuse, equal to 0.188, is positive and significant and at a weak level. The results of random effects show that the relationship between parental addiction and child abuse in the 5 hypotheses examined is equal to 0.388, positive and significant, and moderate. Finally, the relationship between physical and psychological problems of parents and child abuse, equal to 0.268, is positive and significant and evaluated at a weak level.

 

  1. B) The relationship between the characteristics of the victim and his harassment

The results of the study showed that some factors and special characteristics of children increase the risk of abuse. The two variables of age and gender indicate the characteristics of children and affect them as a result of their victimization of violence. The results of random effects show that gender differences also lead to differences in the extent and severity of the child. is harassed. In a way, the relationship between child sex and child abuse in the 6 hypotheses examined is equal to 0.089, positive and significant, and to a very weak extent. Also, the relationship between child age and child abuse is positive and significant in the 5 hypotheses examined, equal to 0.247. Thus, the independent variable of child age has an almost moderate effect on child abuse.

 

Conclusion

According to the research findings, it can be said that the focus of programs and practical and theoretical measures to reduce violence against children should first of all be on the family system and relationships and interactions between family members. It is noteworthy that considering the cultural context of the Iranian-Islamic society and the deep-rooted religious spirit among Iranian families, one can learn from the teachings of Islam in the field of interactions and actions between parents. And the parent-child benefited. Teachings that can be effective by considering special subtleties and paying attention to the child-adult temperaments and the rights and duties of the two. In this way, an effective step can be taken to reduce child abuse in society. The culture-centered approach, which views violence against children as an educational principle, must also be changed. In this regard, efforts should be made to make members of the community aware that child abuse will have negative effects, even based on a reformist and educational orientation. In addition, measures can be taken at the governmental and governmental levels. Among them is the adoption and implementation of up-to-date and comprehensive laws to protect children in the legal system of society, so that child abusers, both at the family level and the external level can be punished for violence. Reach for it.

 

Ethical Considerations 

Compliance with ethical guidelines

This study has been carried out following the ethical codes of human research.

Funding: The present study was conducted without the financial support of the organization or any other person.

Authors’ contribution: The lead author was in charge of writing the text of the article and the second author was in charge of supervising and guiding the writing.

Conflict of interest: This research does not directly or indirectly conflict with legal and real interests.

Acknowledgments: All research participants who have cooperated with the researcher to collect research data are appreciated. The word counts above are a suggestion to keep the material balanced. Deviations are allowed.

Azazi, Shahla. (2001). sociology of family. Roshangaran and Womens studies Publications [Text in Persian]. [link].
Belsky, J. (1993). Etiology of child maltreatment: A developmental ecological analysis. Psychological Bulletin. 114: 413- 434. 10.1037/0033-2909.114.3.413 [link].
Borenstein, M., Hedges, L., Higgins, J., & Rothstein, H. (2009). introduction to Meta-analysis. UK: Wiley and Sons Publication. [link].
Cohen, J. (1977). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences: (Rev. Ed.). New York: Academic Press. [link].
Daneshmandi, S., Izadikhah, Z., & mehrabi, H. A. (2018). The structural model of relationship between child maltreatment, interpersonal skills and borderline personality traits in women population. Journal of Woman and Family Studies, 6 (2): 924. [Text in Persian]. 10.22051/JWFS.2017.15931.1479 [link].
Hemmati, R. (2003). Factors Affecting Men's Violence Against Women in Tehran Families. Master Thesis in Social Science Research. Shahid Beheshti University [Text in Persian]. [link].
Hooman, H. A. (2008). Scientific guide to meta-analysis in scientific research. Samat. [link]
Kaplan, H., Zadok, B., & Garb, J. (1997). Summary of Psychiatry, Behavioral Sciences and Clinical Psychiatry. Volume I. translated by Nusratullah Pourafkari. Shahrab [Text in Persian]. [link].
Khakrangin, M., & Fathi, M. (2009). Familial Factors Contributing to Child Abuse.   Social Welfare Quarterly. 8 (33):123-145. [Text in Persian]. [link].
Marvasti, J. A. (2000). Child suffering in the world: Child maltreatment by parents, culture and governments in different countries and cultures. Manchester: Sexual Trauma Center Publication. [link].
Ortega, L. (2011). doing synthesis and meta-analysis in applied linguistics. Invited workshop at Tsing Hue University. Taipei. [link].
Pornaji, B. (2008). death in silent (a look at the phenomenon of child abuse). Hamshari Publications [Text in Persian]. [link].
Pritchard, C. (2004). The child abusers: Research and controversy. London: Open University Press. [link].
Sotoudeh, H. (2001). Social Pathology. Besat Publicatins. [Text in Persian]. [link].
Vizeh, U., Moradi, Sh., Fadai, Z., & Habibi Asgarabad, M. (2008). A Comparative Study of the Prevalence of Child Abuse in High School Students by Gender, Education and Divorce History in the Family. Family Research Quarterly. 4(14): 165-145 [Text in Persian]. [link].
Walker, C. E., Kaufman, K. L., & Bonner, B. L. (1988). The physically and sexually abused children: Evaluation and treatment. New York: Pergamum. [link].
WHO. (1994). protocol for the study of interpersonal physical abuse of children. Geneva. WHO/FHE/CHD/ 94. 1. [link].
Wisdom, C. S. (1989). Does violence beget violence? A critical examination of the literature. Psychological Balletin. 106 (2). 10.1037/0033-2909.106.1.3 [link].