A Grounded Theory of Insecurity Feeling in Women during the Corona Pandemic

Document Type : Research/Original/Regular

Author

faculty member

Abstract

The medical, social, cultural, and economic implications of Covid 19 have been far-reaching, and not limited to those affected. Rather, it has had profound and far-reaching effects on the body of society and society as a whole and has caused a sense of insecurity in society, especially women. Achieve. The study method of this research is qualitative and examines the subject with a grounded theory approach. Data were collected through interviews. After conducting the interviews, data analysis was performed based on the three stages of open, axial and selective coding and micro-line analysis. Using the theoretical and purposeful sampling method, 26 women in Neyriz city of Fars province were interviewed. In this study, sampling strategy with maximum diversity was used and sampling of women with different age and sex spectrum and different economic and social bases continued until the theoretical saturation reached. The key categories found in the study are: gender socialization, social phobia, lack of institutional support, double control, helplessness, mental breakdown, social isolation, institutionalized fear and distrust. The results of this study show that women in Corona pandemic have experienced feelings of insecurity in various areas (life, financial, psychological and social).

Highlights

of death), distrust (pessimism).

 

Conclusion

Security is one of the basic human needs, which is most important after physiological needs. Security has a relative nature, which means that it varies depending on the individuals' lifeworld and lived experience. The feeling of security is a very complex and multidimensional concept that ignoring it will have adverse consequences, and its absence causes fear and panic, mistrust and distress in society. People in the community should feel physically and mentally peace in the Corona pandemics in the country. Still, in the meantime, the women's feeling of total security is fundamental due to their crucial educational role in the family and society.

According to Barry Buzan and Ole Waever, who proposed that the starting point of security is subjective and based on the actors' decisions, women, based on their interpretation of Corona pandemics, view the situation as a significant threat and catastrophe to their individual and social life. They see their financial, psychological, and social security at risk, which these dimensions are clearly seen in the present study. Women's feelings of insecurity in the Corona pandemic were divided into four dimensions: feelings of insecurity (survival, financial, psychological, and social), and the results suggest that women have experienced feelings of insecurity in various areas.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Extended abstract

Background & Purpose

The coronavirus is still unknown to the world and has hidden dimensions and consequences that need to be addressed by survey and case study research. There are no studies on women's insecurity in the corona pandemic, or its results have not been published yet. Because of the broad consequences of this disease for different groups, especially women, in different parts of the country, and challenges and problems that deserve attention and reflection, there is a need for research in this area. For this reason, we choose one of the regions in the country (Neyriz city in Fars province) to  respond to the following questions:

1) What are the underlying reasons for women's Corona-related feelings of insecurity?; 2) What strategies do women use to deal with this feeling of insecurity?; 3) what are the consequences of women's Corona-related feelings of insecurity?; And 4) What are the dimensions of women's experience of insecurity?

Review of Literature

This study is more inspired by the theories of security analysts by the Copenhagen School, and undoubtedly, the most influential experts who addressed this variable are Barry Buzan and Ole Wæver. Buzan defines the starting point of security as subjective and based on the actors' decisions. He argued that security is known in the community because actors can refer to it and view some events as threats. Simply put, the levels of security or insecurity depend on individuals' perceptions and their security-related appraisals. Barry Buzan once quotes John Locke in saying that the primary purpose of human beings in giving authority to the government is to preserve their property. Property here means life, survival, freedom, political and intellectual security, and financial security.

 

Method

Current research is an applied study in terms of purpose. The methodology used in this research is qualitative with the grounded theory approach, which aims to explore the semantic implications of insecurity feelings in women during the Corona pandemic. In the present study, in-depth interviews were used to collect data. After transcribing the interviews, the data were analyzed using three open, axial, and selective coding steps. We conducted interviews in summer 2020 in the city of Neyriz, Fars province. All participants signed the informed consent form. Each interview lasts approximately an hour and is carried out in public places such as offices, shopping centers, parks, and streets. The sample size consisted of 26 women in Neyriz selected among the statistical population.

 

Results

Causal conditions

Causal conditions refer to events that lead to a feeling of insecurity in women. In this article, the causal conditions of women's insecurity can be considered as gender role socialization (women's restrictions, learned fear).

Context

Contextual conditions are a specific set of conditions that accumulate at a particular time and place to set the stage for forming a phenomenon. (Strauss and Corbin, 2012, 154). In other words, the contextual conditions provide the context for women to feel insecure. In the present study, these conditions are the lack of institutional policy-making (poverty) and social anxiety and panic (media advertising, cyberspace).

Interfering conditions

Interfering conditions are those that alleviate, aggravate, or modify causal conditions. Thus, being controlled (psychological insecurity, lack of freedom) can be mentioned as an Interfering condition that intensifies the feelings of insecurity in the women in our study.

Strategies

Strauss and Corbin stated that the goal of the strategies in grounded theory is to manage, deal with, and show sensitivity to the phenomenon. The present study suggested dual strategies. These strategies include helplessness or despair (accepting the situation, tolerance), women's vulnerability (social exclusion, economic inequality).

consequences

The actions and reactions that take place to deal with the phenomenon will have consequences. In the present study, the conditions that create a sense of insecurity in the Corona pandemic will lead to four consequences, which are:

Psychological burnout (depression, distress), social isolation (social insecurity, internal insecurity), internalization of fear (feeling of death), distrust (pessimism).

 

Conclusion

Security is one of the basic human needs, which is most important after physiological needs. Security has a relative nature, which means that it varies depending on the individuals' lifeworld and lived experience. The feeling of security is a very complex and multidimensional concept that ignoring it will have adverse consequences, and its absence causes fear and panic, mistrust and distress in society. People in the community should feel physically and mentally peace in the Corona pandemics in the country. Still, in the meantime, the women's feeling of total security is fundamental due to their crucial educational role in the family and society.

According to Barry Buzan and Ole Waever, who proposed that the starting point of security is subjective and based on the actors' decisions, women, based on their interpretation of Corona pandemics, view the situation as a significant threat and catastrophe to their individual and social life. They see their financial, psychological, and social security at risk, which these dimensions are clearly seen in the present study. Women's feelings of insecurity in the Corona pandemic were divided into four dimensions: feelings of insecurity (survival, financial, psychological, and social), and the results suggest that women have experienced feelings of insecurity in various areas.

Ahmadi ,M &  Kaldi, A. (2012). A study of women's sense of social security in Sanandaj and the social factors affecting it. Journal of Women and Society, 3 (4): 1-19.,.(Text in Persian)
Aazazi, S. (1998). Sociology of the family with emphasis on the role of family structure and function in the contemporary era. Tehran: Intellectuals and Women's Studies Publications, .(Text in Persian)
Askari, M, 2006. Feasibility study of determining indicators for measuring the national security coefficient of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Strategic Information Monthly - Center for Strategic Defense Research, 4.(44) : 76-96.(Text in Persian)
Bayat, B. (2009). Investigating the Factors Affecting Tehran Citizens' Sense of Security (with Emphasis on Mass Media, Police Performance and Crime), Social Order Quarterly, 1(1) .(Text in Persian)
Bizaban, A. Tajbakhsh, G & Moradi Nejad, Z. (2012). The study of the relationship between social capital and the sense of social security of the family, a case study: Khorramabad city. Social Security Studies Quarterly, 4, (30),:53-75.,.(Text in Persian)
Barker, Chris (2003), Cultural Studies, London: Blackwell.
Buzan, B & weaver, O. (1998). "liberalism and security: the contradiction of the liberal leviathan", copen hayen peace research in statue (COPRI) working papers.
Chutner, I. 2020. How do global diseases change history? Hamoon Neyshabouri's translation published in our collection of articles and Corona. Published by Aso.
De Certeau, M. (1997). Practice of Everyday Life, Translatedby Steven Rendall, Berkeley, Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Electronic newsletter of the Iranian Psychological Association. (2020). Corona Special Letter http://iranpa.org/.(Text in Persian)
Eftekhari, A & Nasiri, A. (2004). Methods and Theory in Security Studies, Tehran: Research Institute for Strategic Studies. .(Text in Persian)
Giddens, A. (1996). Modernity and individuality, society and personal identity in the new age. Translated by Nasser Movafeghian, Tehran, Ney Publishing. .(Text in Persian)
Giddens, A. 1997. Sociology, translated by Manouchehr Sabouri, third edition, Tehran: Ney Publishing. .(Text in Persian)
Glaser, B., G. & A. L. Strauss, (1967): The Discovery of Grounded Theory, Sterategies for Qualitative Research. London: Weidenfeild and Nicolson.
Ghafari,G,2011, Social Capital and Disciplinary Security, First Edition, Tehran, Publication of the Research and Studies Organization of the Disciplinary Research Institute. .(Text in Persian)
Hosseini, M, Khazaei, S & Gholami, F. 2019, The lived experience of divorced women from feeling insecure in daily life, Women's Research Journal, 10(4). 25-52, .(Text in Persian)
Rush, M. 2004. Society and Politics, An Introduction to Political Sociology, translated by Manouchehr Sabouri, Tehran: Samat.
Roshani, S, Gharavi Naeini, N & Bastani, S, (2015), The experience of women feeling comfortable in married life: A qualitative study with a basic theory approach, Women and Family Studies, 3(2) 61-89., .(Text in Persian)
Raeisi Sadati, R (2013), Violence against Women from the Perspective of Quranic Interpretations, Women and Family Studies, 1(1): 119-158,.(Text in Persian)
Lorne, M. 2005. Sociology of Security, Tehran: Ramin Publishing. .(Text in Persian)
Jijeck.S. 2020. The decision imposed on us by the coronavirus: Global Communism or the Law of the Jungle. Translated by Saleh Najafi. In the collection of Corona virus and philosophers. Site Aso.
 Kaldi, A, 2005. Social Capital and Family. Proceedings of the First Symposium on Social Capital and Social Welfare, Tehran, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences Publications. .(Text in Persian)
Movahed, M & Hemmat, S. 2013. Cultural and social factors related to women's sense of social security. Journal of Women and Society, 4(2),: 55-82. (Text in Persian)
Moradi, D, 2020, Corona Crisis and Changes in Reproductive Behavior, Corona and Iranian Society, Tehran, Institute of Communication Arts Culture. .(Text in Persian)
Mandal, R. 2000. The Changing Face of National Security, translated by the Institute for Strategic Studies, Tehran: Institute for Strategic Studies.
Mohseni Tabrizi, A. (2012). Sociological study of social impact on the sense of social security in worn-out areas (Case study of Shahid Asadi neighborhood in District 13 of Tehran Municipality). Master Thesis: University of Tehran. .(Text in Persian)
Navidnia, M. 2009, Social Security, Tehran: Research Institute for Strategic Studies, First Edition.(Text in Persian)
Qaderzadeh, O& Darvish Manesh, M. 2017, Qualitative study of the causes and consequences of the disease, Iranian social issues, 8(1), .(Text in Persian)
Qaderzadeh, O& Khazaei, S. 2014, A qualitative study of the semantic implications of women's insecurity in public spaces, Women in Development and Politics, 12(3): 405-425. .(Text in Persian)
Torabi, Y & Goodarzi, A. 2004. Values ​​and Social Security, Proceedings of the Social Security Conference, NAJA Social Affairs, Tehran: Golpouyeh Publications, .(Text in Persian)
Tajbakhsh, G. 2016. An Introduction to the Sociology of Indian Society, Isfahan: Asman Negar, .(Text in Persian)
Tajbakhsh, G. 2021. Lived experiences of people facing coronary heart disease, Quarterly Journal of Education and Community Health, Winter Issue. .(Text in Persian)
Zareian, M, Safarbeigi, S, Ghasemi,M& Chabaki, U (2020). The Relationship between Social Participation and the Feeling of Security in Women in Ilam, Women and Family Studies, 8 (1): 215-245,. (Text in Persian).  [link]